Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Milburn’s historic report on Britain’s lost generation says one key thing: finally, young lives will really matter | Polly Toynbee
Alan Milburn’s year-long inquiry into the roughly one million UK 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training has prompted a broad set of proposed policies. Polly Toynbee argues the report’s greater significance is a shift in political priorities: treating young people’s prospects as a central responsibility, after years of cuts to services and support.
The proposals bring schools, colleges, health services, councils and employers together, with mayors or councils accountable for reducing the number of young people who are NEET. Local youth hubs would offer advice, work experience, supported internships and help with mental health; employers may receive incentives to hire young people aged 21 to 24 in retail and hospitality. The report also proposes restoring education maintenance allowances for care leavers, with possible expansion to sixth-formers on free school meals.
In short
- Milburn’s report proposes coordinated support for young people who are NEET.
- Local youth hubs would link employment, education and health services.
- The author says the key change is making young people a priority.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A coordinated national and local effort could help young people whose barriers span education, work, health and family circumstances, rather than leaving each service to act alone. Youth hubs, targeted financial support and employer incentives may give those at greatest risk practical routes into training and stable work, while accountability could make it harder for institutions to overlook them.
The case against
The proposals may expand public responsibilities and spending without showing that the measures will reliably reduce long-term disengagement or lead to secure, worthwhile work. Giving local authorities or mayors responsibility for outcomes they cannot fully control could add bureaucracy, and employer incentives risk subsidising recruitment that would have happened anyway; support should therefore be judged against clear evidence and competing demands on public funds.
Explained simply
In the UK, “NEET” describes young people who are not in education, employment or training. The term covers people with different circumstances, including those looking for work and those facing barriers such as poor health or limited support.
Alan Milburn is a former health secretary who led an inquiry into the issue. Its proposals involve schools, colleges, health services, councils and employers, reflecting how support for young people can span several parts of public life.
The issue matters because time out of education or work can affect young people’s skills, income and future opportunities. Education maintenance allowances are payments intended to help some students with costs while studying; care leavers are young adults who have been in local authority care.