Push Square's mini-review of No More Room in Hell 2 on PS5 praises the co-op zombie shooter for restoring genuine tension to the genre, thanks to deliberately clunky, Resident Evil-style gunplay, scarce ammunition and oppressive darkness. The reviewer found the slow-paced, PvPvE extraction format immersive and tactile, arguing it makes even shuffling undead feel genuinely dangerous, though the console port shows rough edges after transitioning from PC.

The game tasks up to eight players with looting six large maps and completing objectives before extracting, while contending with weak, exposed characters and weapon-specific ammunition rather than a constant ammo counter. Torches are only usable with one-handed weapons, forcing tactical trade-offs between visibility and firepower during missions such as clearing a darkened power station. However, having spent two years in PC early access, the console version suffers from a clunky radial inventory wheel and cluttered, unintuitive UI reminiscent of Arma Reforger on PS5, which the reviewer cites as the game's main drawback.