Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
MP criticises Guernsey and Jersey company ownership register plans
Sir Andrew Mitchell has criticised proposed changes to company ownership registers in Guernsey and Jersey, arguing that restricted access could prevent investigators from uncovering financial crime. The plans would let journalists, academics and others with a legitimate interest apply to see information, but Mitchell says they should lead to fully public registers.
The proposals follow a 2023 commitment by Guernsey, Jersey and the Isle of Man to improve transparency and tackle money laundering, terrorist financing and other crimes. Jersey says applicants may need to show they have exhausted reasonable alternative sources; Guernsey’s published response does not explicitly include that requirement. Both island governments reject Mitchell’s criticism, saying their plans meet international standards while balancing access with privacy and protection for vulnerable people.
In short
- Mitchell says the proposed access limits could hinder investigations.
- Jersey may require applicants to exhaust other information sources.
- Both islands say their plans meet international standards.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Fully public ownership registers could help journalists, researchers and investigators identify who controls companies and trace suspected illicit funds across borders. Requiring people to prove a legitimate interest or exhaust other sources may delay scrutiny or exclude those who cannot meet the test, so open access could make the commitment to tackling financial crime more effective.
The case against
Restricted access can still enable scrutiny while limiting the exposure of personal information that could endanger vulnerable people or intrude on privacy. A process for applicants with a legitimate interest may meet international standards and allow relevant investigations, while avoiding the risks of making ownership details available to anyone.