World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Parents risk their home by guaranteeing a child’s mortgage
A father in his early 60s is weighing his son’s request for him and his wife to guarantee a mortgage using their paid-off home as security. Money educator Vanessa Stoykov and financial adviser Harry Moustakas say his hesitation is justified: a guarantee can make parents legally responsible for the debt and put their home and retirement security at risk.
They illustrate the potential shortfall with a $1 million purchase funded by a $950,000 mortgage: if the property falls 10 per cent in value and must be sold, proceeds may not cover the debt and selling costs. They suggest first reviewing retirement finances with an adviser and discussing repayments, rate rises, insurance and emergency savings with the couple. Limited guarantees, cash security, a documented family loan or paying for the son to get financial advice may be alternatives, each requiring independent advice.
In short
- A mortgage guarantee could put the parents’ home at risk.
- A falling property price may leave a debt shortfall.
- Independent advice and other forms of help are worth considering.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Guaranteeing the mortgage could help the son buy a home sooner, potentially avoiding years of rising rents and giving the family a chance to support him when he needs it. If the parents can afford the exposure, understand the legal terms and agree clear limits and repayment safeguards, they may see the risk as a considered use of family resources.
The case against
The guarantee could leave the parents liable for a debt they did not take on for themselves, putting their paid-off home and retirement plans at risk if repayments fail or the property sale does not cover the loan. Even with safeguards, their exposure may be difficult to predict, so protecting their long-term financial security can reasonably take priority over helping their son buy now.
Explained simply
A mortgage is a loan used to buy a home, and a guarantee is a promise to repay it if the borrower cannot. When parents use their own home as security, the lender may be able to claim against it if the child falls behind on repayments.
The people involved are the child borrowing to buy a home, the lender providing the mortgage and the parents asked to guarantee it. The parents’ own finances matter because the commitment could affect their home and the money they have set aside for retirement.
If a home has to be sold after its value falls, the sale may not raise enough to repay the loan and selling costs. Any shortfall could leave the guarantors exposed, so the arrangement can affect the whole family’s financial security.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “My son wants me to use our paid-off home to secure his mortgage. The risk terrifies me. What should I do? VANESSA STOYKOV”.