NADINE DORRIES: I have witnessed first-hand what happens to new Prime Ministers when they enter No 10… and this is why Andy Burnham will be out by May
In a Daily Mail column, former Conservative culture secretary Nadine Dorries draws on her own experience of government to predict that Andy Burnham, having just become Prime Minister, will struggle to survive in the role beyond May. She argues that the sheer scale and speed of decisions facing a new PM, combined with Burnham's lack of prior top-level experience, will quickly overwhelm him, echoing what she witnessed when Boris Johnson entered Number 10.
Dorries describes the disorienting first days of a premiership: intense security briefings with intelligence chiefs, signing the "letters of last resort" for Britain's nuclear submarine commanders, and back-to-back briefings every 15 minutes as officials bring the new leader up to speed. She suggests Burnham will lose control over his own time, diary and even his wardrobe, with civil servants now dictating his schedule and dress for formal duties, while ambitious MPs, union leaders and other figures bombard him with demands and congratulations.
In short
- Nadine Dorries predicts new PM Andy Burnham won't last past May.
- She likens his overwhelm to Boris Johnson's early days in No 10.
- Cites nuclear briefings, packed schedules and loss of personal control.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Dorries' analysis would argue she is drawing on genuine first-hand experience of Downing Street's opening days, having watched Boris Johnson grapple with the same avalanche of security briefings, nuclear protocols and diary loss she describes. From this view, her warning is a reasonable, non-partisan observation about the structural shock any incoming premier faces, made more pointed by the fact that Burnham has never held the very top offices of state that typically prepare a leader for such intensity. Seen this way, the piece offers a useful insider's corrective to the public's rosy expectations of a smooth transition, rather than a personal attack.
The case against
Critics would counter that Dorries is a former Conservative minister and long-standing ally of Johnson with an evident partisan stake in seeing a Labour-aligned figure like Burnham falter, which colours a prediction dressed up as neutral insight. They would note that every new prime minister, regardless of prior experience, faces the same briefings and loss of personal time, so framing this as a specific vulnerability of Burnham's risks pre-judging his tenure before he has had a chance to govern. On this view, the column reads less as dispassionate analysis and more as a rival party figure using her insider credentials to seed doubt about a new opponent's competence.