Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Net zero is an egregiously bad deal for the UK
Bjorn Lomborg argues that reaching net zero by 2050 would cost the UK far more than the climate damage it would prevent. His analysis uses climate and economic estimates drawn from UN modelling and argues that the figures should be weighed openly when governments make climate policy.
The article estimates that UK net zero would lower global temperatures in 2100 by 0.0038°C, while costing £70.3bn a year by 2045 and £695bn over the century in today’s money. It puts the resulting global climate benefits at £74bn, or 11p for each pound spent. For the world as a whole, it estimates net zero would avoid $24tn in climate damage but cost $255tn.
In short
- UK net zero would make a tiny difference to global temperatures.
- The article estimates £695bn in UK costs over the century.
- It argues the climate benefits would be much smaller than the costs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the article’s argument say climate policy should be judged against its costs and measurable benefits, including the very small effect one country’s emissions cuts may have on global temperatures. If the estimates are sound, spending hundreds of billions of pounds for benefits valued far below that amount could divert resources from priorities such as health, adaptation and cheaper emissions reductions.
The case against
Defenders of net zero argue that the UK’s contribution should be assessed as part of a collective effort: emissions cuts by one country have limited effect alone, but coordinated action can reduce risks that no country can avoid by acting in isolation. They may also question estimates that assign a precise monetary value to long-term climate damage while giving less weight to uncertainty, severe risks and benefits such as cleaner air, energy security and technological development.