Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Netflix’s Biggest Sci-Fi Creature Feature Could Succeed Where Apple TV+’s ‘Monarch’ Fell Short
Collider argues that Netflix’s forthcoming thriller Below could appeal to viewers who wanted more creature-focused action from Apple TV+’s Monarch: Legacy of Monsters. The comparison matters because both programmes centre on dangerous giant creatures, but Below appears to favour a contained, suspense-led story over extensive franchise mythology and multiple timelines.
Below is due to premiere on 8 October 2026 and stars Josh Hartnett as Calvin Penney, a Newfoundland fisherman confronting a mysterious sea creature while investigating his father’s long-ago death. Created by Jesse McKeown, it also stars Mackenzie Davis as a marine biologist, alongside Charlie Heaton, Willow Kean, Ruby Stokes, Rohan Campbell and Kaleb Horn; the article notes that its potential remains speculative before release.
In short
- Netflix’s Below premieres on 8 October 2026.
- It follows a Newfoundland town threatened by a sea creature.
- Collider expects a tighter monster thriller than Monarch.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A focused narrative centred on creature action and suspense offers viewers more immediate satisfaction and emotional engagement. Audiences drawn to creature features value streamlined storytelling that avoids complex mythology or timeline jumps, which can impede pacing and require extensive viewing commitments. A contained story like Below allows direct confrontation between protagonist and creature, building tension through character stakes rather than franchise expansion.
The case against
Creature fiction gains depth and imaginative scope through rich mythology and interconnected storytelling. Audiences seeking sophisticated engagement find reward in world-building that extends across timelines and narrative threads, creating layered narratives with franchise potential. A contained story risks being narratively reductive, treating creature-features as simple survival tales rather than opportunities to explore complex ecosystems, history, and lore that elevate the genre beyond surface-level suspense.
Explained simply
Monarch: Legacy of Monsters is an Apple TV+ series set in the world of Godzilla and other giant creatures. It follows people connected to a secret organisation called Monarch, using events across different periods to explore how humans respond to these beings.
Below is a forthcoming Netflix thriller about Calvin Penney, a Newfoundland fisherman played by Josh Hartnett, who encounters a mysterious sea creature while looking into his father’s death. The cast also includes Mackenzie Davis as a marine biologist. Both programmes feature dangerous creatures, but their different approaches may appeal to viewers for different reasons; how Below will be received remains uncertain before its release.
Art Culture Entertainment Horror TV