Trump attacks Canada after trade talks collapse amid tariffs

Developed over time first seen 2 months ago

The Guardian · 2 months ago

The US-Canada trade dispute has settled into an active tariff war after negotiations collapsed in Washington, with President Trump accusing Canada of wanting "the benefits of being a State, without being one" and rejecting further concessions on farm tariffs. The breakdown, which both sides blame on the other, has seen the US impose 50% tariffs on $20bn (£14.6bn) of Canadian goods covering items from hockey sticks to tongue depressors, while Prime Minister Mark Carney says Canada was "attacked" and will respond "dollar for dollar" with matching levies on steel, dairy, appliances and electronics from 8 September.

Officials estimate the tariffs will hit around 40% of small Canadian exporters directly, with nearly a third fearing revenue falls of 50% or more, while the US insists the move protects American workers after a year of Canadian retaliation. The row has also drawn criticism from Democratic politicians in US border states and cast doubt over the future of the USMCA trade pact, after Trump declined to renew the deal this summer; relations have deteriorated further amid falling Canadian tourism to the US and a petition calling for the expulsion of the US ambassador to Canada.

US-Canada trade talks collapsed, triggering tit-for-tat tariffs
US imposed 50% tariffs on $20bn of Canadian goods
Carney to match tariffs; USMCA pact's future now in doubt

New here? Start with this

Trump and Canadian prime minister Mark Carney are locked in a worsening trade dispute after talks between the two countries broke down in Washington. The US has imposed steep tariffs of 50% on a wide range of Canadian goods, and Canada has said it will respond with matching tariffs of its own on a range of sectors.

The row centres on longstanding disagreements over tariffs, particularly ones affecting American farmers, which Trump says Canada has unfairly imposed for years. It also touches on the USMCA, a decades-old free trade agreement between the US, Canada and Mexico worth roughly $2tn a year, which Trump has so far declined to renew.

The dispute matters because Canada and the US are among each other's largest trading partners, and rising tariffs could raise costs for businesses and consumers on both sides of the border. It also raises broader questions about the stability of North American trade relations at a time when the future of the wider USMCA pact is in doubt.

Both sides, in good faith

The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.

The case for

Supporters of Trump's hard line argue that Canada has long shielded politically sensitive sectors, particularly dairy, behind steep tariff and quota barriers that keep US farmers out of a market on their doorstep, and that decades of polite negotiation failed to shift this. They see tariffs as the only lever that has ever forced trading partners to the table, and view refusing to renew USMCA on the old terms as a reasonable demand for reciprocity rather than one-sided access. From this perspective, a confrontational stance protects American producers and asserts that continental trade should not simply be assumed to continue on autopilot.

The case against

Critics, including the Canadian government, argue that abrupt 50% tariffs on everyday goods punish ordinary consumers and businesses in both countries and needlessly destabilise an integrated economic relationship built up over decades under NAFTA and USMCA. They see language suggesting Canada should behave like a US state as dismissive of its sovereignty, and view walking away from a treaty worth some $2tn annually as reckless brinkmanship that invites retaliation, as seen in Canada's matching tariffs, rather than a considered negotiating strategy. From this perspective, predictable rules-based trade, not sudden unilateral pressure, is what actually serves workers and industries on both sides of the border.

More coverage

Americas Business Government Markets Politics World

Read the full article at the source →

Originally published by The Guardian as “‘No more!!!’: Trump lashes out after US-Canada talks devolve into trade war”.