World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘No viable suggestions’ on Russian assets yet, Belgium’s Euroclear tells European Parliament
Euroclear told a European Parliament hearing that proposals discussed so far for using immobilised Russian state assets to support Ukraine do not adequately address the risks to financial institutions or markets. The debate has gained urgency after the European Commission proposed a further €45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027, raising concerns about future debt costs for European taxpayers.
Euroclear held €204 billion in Russian government assets as of September, most of the total held in the EU. The company warned that uncertainty over asset protection and the rule of law could deter investors and increase Europe’s borrowing costs; it said Russian countermeasures had already cost it €233 million in October, mostly in legal fees. An activist proposal to transfer the assets to another European custodian includes compensation provisions, but its author has not specified how the EU would reimburse Euroclear or Belgium.
In short
- Euroclear says current plans for Russian assets do not adequately manage financial risks.
- The company held €204 billion in Russian state assets in September.
- Russian countermeasures cost Euroclear €233 million in October.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Using immobilised Russian state assets to support Ukraine could reduce the burden of financing its defence and recovery on European taxpayers, while making Russia bear some of the costs of its aggression. Supporters may argue that carefully designed safeguards and compensation can address custodial risks, and that leaving the assets untouched carries its own moral and strategic costs.
The case against
Euroclear and other critics can argue that using sovereign assets without a clear legal basis and reliable protection for custodians could expose financial institutions and Belgium to retaliation, litigation and losses. If investors conclude that assets held in Europe are vulnerable to political decisions, confidence could weaken and European borrowing costs rise, shifting costs back to taxpayers.
Explained simply
After Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, the European Union froze Russian central bank assets held in Europe. The assets remain Russian property, but Russia cannot access them. Euroclear, a Belgium-based financial company that holds securities for clients, holds much of this frozen money.
European governments are discussing whether the assets, or the earnings they generate, could help fund Ukraine. Any use raises legal and financial questions, including who would cover possible claims by Russia and whether investors might see European financial rules as less reliable. The debate matters because Ukraine needs continued funding, while decisions about the assets could affect Europe’s financial system and the cost of borrowing.
Europe Government Politics World