‘Nobody Wants This’ star accuses Israel of ‘genocide’
Actor Adam Brody said he believes Israel is committing “genocide” in Gaza and supports a free Palestine, adding that he hopes a future US administration will change policies contributing to the situation. His comments, made in an interview about his political activism, add him to a group of progressive public figures speaking out on the conflict.
Brody also said Hollywood had become more conservative and that political activism there had waned during Donald Trump’s second presidency, which he described as a riskier time to speak out. He said activism was beginning to pick up again ahead of the next election. A conservative commentator disputed Brody’s account of the risks, arguing that progressive views remain advantageous in Hollywood.
- Adam Brody called Israel’s actions in Gaza “genocide” and backed a free Palestine.
- He said Hollywood has become more conservative during Trump’s second term.
- A conservative commentator challenged his claim that speaking out carries risks.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Those agreeing with Brody's characterisation point to the extensive civilian casualties, displacement, and destruction in Gaza, alongside statements from Israeli officials expressing intent toward collective punishment or demographic change. They argue this meets the legal threshold for genocide under international law, particularly when considering the disparity in military power and civilian harm. They further contend that unconditional US military support enables this harm and represents a departure from American values, making public criticism not merely justified but morally necessary despite potential professional consequences.
The case against
Those disputing this view argue that Israel is conducting a lawful military campaign against Hamas, which initiated conflict and deliberately embeds itself within civilian populations. They emphasise that tragic civilian casualties resulting from legitimate military operations differ fundamentally from genocidal intent; Israel's stated objective is eliminating Hamas, not Palestinians as a people. They note that many Palestinians live safely within Israel and that demographic projections show Palestinian population growth, inconsistent with genocide. Regarding Hollywood, they contend that progressive and pro-Palestinian views remain culturally dominant, suggesting that claims of significant professional risk for such speech are overstated.