New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Now is the time to embrace change and The Age of Ideas
Darren Hemmings, founder of music marketing company Motive Unknown, argues that artists and labels should reduce their reliance on social media as its ability to connect them with fans weakens. He says the shift matters because businesses built around platform engagement risk losing audience access and value to companies such as Meta and Google.
Hemmings says labels have recently reported falling engagement and uncertainty about what to do next. He advocates owning and using fan data to build lasting relationships and revenue, guided by long-term frameworks rather than quick fixes. Motive Unknown is marking its 15th anniversary with a team of about 30 and has launched a retail division serving clients including Rough Trade, Sub Pop and Bertus/Musiconvinyl.
In short
- Hemmings says social media is losing its grip on music marketing.
- Labels report falling engagement and uncertainty.
- He urges artists to own fan data and build lasting connections.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Artists and labels have good reason to rely less on social platforms: declining engagement and changing platform rules can make access to fans unreliable, while platforms capture much of the value. Building direct relationships and responsibly using fan data could give music businesses more control and support lasting income.
The case against
Social platforms still offer artists and labels a large, convenient way to reach fans, promote releases and discover audiences without first building their own channels. Shifting resources towards direct data and relationships may be costly and less effective for smaller acts, and could overlook the platforms’ continuing value as part of a broader strategy.
Explained simply
Social media platforms such as Instagram, Facebook and YouTube have become important routes for artists and record labels to reach listeners. But audiences and visibility on these services are controlled by the platforms, whose rules and recommendation systems can change.
Darren Hemmings runs Motive Unknown, a music marketing company that advises artists and labels. He argues that they can build more lasting contact with fans by collecting and using fan information directly, rather than relying so heavily on social media engagement.
The issue matters because labels depend on reaching listeners to promote music and earn revenue, while platforms can capture much of the value created by audience attention. Motive Unknown has also expanded into retail, working with companies including Rough Trade, Sub Pop and Bertus/Musiconvinyl.