Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Now You See Me Live review – magic so bombastic it may be visible from space
The Guardian's review of Now You See Me Live, playing at the London Coliseum ahead of a planned run in Las Vegas, finds the stage spin-off of the film franchise packed with genuine magic skill but let down by excessive spectacle. The show follows four illusionists dubbed "the Horsemen" performing escapology, mentalism and other tricks, and matters because it illustrates a wider tension in large-scale magic shows between impressive craft and overblown theatrical trappings that can dilute rather than enhance the performances.
The reviewer praises several standout acts, including Italian performer Andrew Basso's recreation of Houdini's water torture escape and a padlocked-chains stunt, French magician Enzo Weyne's paper bag and lightbulb routine, and an audience card-trick set piece. However, the review criticises the show's smoke, lasers and self-promotion, including MC Matthew Pomeroy's claim that the production redresses gender imbalance in magic despite only one of seven performers being female. A quieter card-manipulation cameo from former Britain's Got Talent semi-finalist Eden Choi is singled out as a highlight precisely because it needs no embellishment.
In short
- Now You See Me Live reviewed at London Coliseum before Las Vegas transfer
- Genuine escapology and mentalism skills undermined by bombastic staging
- Eden Choi's understated card trick praised as show's best moment
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A large-scale theatrical production at a major venue like the London Coliseum is precisely meant to be a bombastic, immersive experience; the production values, lighting and effects are integral to creating memorable spectacle rather than detracting from it. Audiences attending a West End show come for theatrical magic, not a demonstration of close-up technique, and the scale and production design create an entertainment experience that craft alone cannot achieve.
The case against
The most impressive and memorable magic happens when the audience's attention is focused on the performer's skill and the mystery itself, without distraction from smoke, lasers and theatrical bombast that can overshadow rather than enhance the performance. Even in a large-scale production, the quietest and most skilfully executed moments resonate most powerfully; excessive spectacle ultimately diminishes the wonder and astonishment that genuine magic should inspire.
Explained simply
Now You See Me Live is a stage show based on the Now You See Me films, which feature a team of illusionists known as the Horsemen. The live production brings together seven performers for tricks including escapes, mentalism and card magic, using large-scale theatre effects as part of the presentation.
The cast includes Italian escape artist Andrew Basso, French magician Enzo Weyne and former Britain’s Got Talent semi-finalist Eden Choi. The show’s mix of skilled performance and elaborate staging reflects a wider question in live magic: how much spectacle helps an illusion, and when it risks distracting from the trick itself.