Weird & Viral news and discussion on TalkFuse.
NYC maniac who killed elderly aunt spent just 13 days in jail for previous senior citizen attack: cops, sources
A 35-year-old man charged with killing his 75-year-old aunt in the Bronx had previously attacked a 66-year-old man, leaving him with a brain bleed, according to police and officials. The case has drawn attention to his earlier sentence: prosecutors sought four years in prison, but a judge imposed 45 days and probation, and he served 13 days.
Prosecutors allege Joshua Nunez dragged and beat his aunt, Carmen Nunez, during a dispute in their apartment building; police found her dying and he surrendered. Authorities have not disclosed a motive. Records cited in the article say Nunez has 10 arrests, including later brief periods in custody and domestic-violence cases; he is being held without bail in the murder case.
In short
- Nunez served 13 days after a prior attack that caused a brain bleed.
- He is charged with killing his 75-year-old aunt in the Bronx.
- Investigators have not disclosed a motive.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The earlier assault reportedly caused a brain bleed, so prosecutors’ request for a substantial prison sentence can be seen as a proportionate response to serious violence and a way to protect the public. The short sentence and 13 days served may prompt concern that the court did not give enough weight to the harm or the risk of further violence.
The case against
A judge may have had reasons, based on the evidence, sentencing law and Nunez’s circumstances, to impose probation and a shorter custodial term; the article does not provide the full basis for that decision. A fair assessment should not treat the later murder charge as proof that the earlier sentence was wrongly set, and sentencing policy should avoid imposing lengthy imprisonment beyond what the earlier offence and individual circumstances warrant.