Sport news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Officials can’t use common sense’ – was Rogers handball correct?
Chelsea’s 4-1 home defeat by Leeds turned when Morgan Rogers conceded a penalty that put the visitors ahead. The decision was widely debated, but the article explains why it was considered correct under the handball law.
Rogers raised his arm towards Jayden Bogle’s shot, which came from distance and gave him time to react; the ball was deflected by the arm rather than reaching his body. The contact appeared to be within the punishable part of the arm, leaving little basis for VAR to overturn referee Michael Oliver’s call. Last season the Premier League awarded 22 handball penalties in 380 matches, compared with 36 in Spain and 38 in Italy.
In short
- Rogers’s raised arm deflected Bogle’s shot.
- The penalty was judged correct under the law.
- Premier League handball penalties remain relatively uncommon.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The penalty can be defended on the grounds that the law is meant to judge the action, not whether the player intended to handle the ball: Rogers raised his arm towards a shot he had time to react to, and the ball struck a punishable part of the arm. If the referee judged that made his body unnaturally larger, upholding the decision was consistent with applying the rule as written.
The case against
The decision can be questioned because handball rules should distinguish deliberate or avoidable contact from an instinctive reaction to a shot, especially when the ball is deflected and the player has little time to adjust. A rigid reading may produce penalties that feel disproportionate to the effect of the contact and undermine confidence in the law; the comparatively low number of Premier League handball penalties does not settle whether this particular call was fair.