News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Oilman Scott Sheffield: ‘We’re warming. I see it here in this ranch’ – Financial Times
The article profiles Scott Sheffield, the veteran US oil executive who helped build Pioneer Natural Resources and transform Texas’s Permian Basin into a major global energy hub. Now retired, Sheffield acknowledges that the climate is warming, citing changes he says he can see on his New Mexico ranch, while continuing to defend the importance of oil and gas to energy security and the economy.
Sheffield’s career spans more than four decades and includes the development of the Permian shale industry, Pioneer’s roughly $60bn sale to ExxonMobil, and a subsequent dispute with the US Federal Trade Commission. The article also examines his views on climate change, the future of fossil fuels and the tensions between the oil industry’s economic success and its contribution to global warming.
In short
- Retired oil pioneer acknowledges visible warming.
- Sheffield helped create the Permian shale boom.
- His legacy reflects oil’s economic gains and climate costs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Climate change is real, but energy security and economic stability remain pressing concerns that cannot be abandoned overnight. The transition away from fossil fuels requires time, alternative sources need to scale, and billions of people depend on affordable energy for basic needs. One can acknowledge warming whilst arguing that a measured, pragmatic approach—maintaining oil and gas during the transition—better serves global welfare than rushing into alternatives that risk economic disruption and energy poverty.
The case against
If climate warming is acknowledged as genuine and caused by fossil fuels, defending their continued expansion becomes fundamentally contradictory and inadequate. The severity of the crisis demands urgent, transformative action rather than incremental change that prolongs reliance on the problem's source. Prioritising economic and energy security arguments over the environmental risks that Sheffield himself observes represents insufficient response to an existential threat.
Explained simply
Scott Sheffield is a long-time US oil executive who led Pioneer Natural Resources as it grew into one of the biggest producers in Texas’s Permian Basin. Advances in drilling helped turn the basin into a major source of oil and gas, bringing investment and jobs to the region.
Sheffield’s career also includes Pioneer’s sale to ExxonMobil, one of the world’s largest energy companies, and a dispute with the US Federal Trade Commission, which reviews business deals and competition. His views reflect a wider debate over how to balance oil and gas’s role in energy supplies and the economy with the greenhouse gas emissions that drive climate change.