World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Old-school Catholic education with daily prayer and Latin classes makes stunning comeback in America’s most liberal city
Nativity High, a new classical Catholic school in San Francisco, has grown from 17 students at its 2024 opening to 60, despite the city’s declining number of children and falling public-school enrolment. Its approach combines daily prayer and Latin with formal uniforms, device restrictions and a curriculum centred on challenging texts, arts and structured discussion.
The school is based at Star of the Sea Parish and draws students from more than 20 countries and varied economic backgrounds; some travel up to two hours to attend. Head of School Diana Adamson expects enrolment to reach 100 next year and says the model responds to teen loneliness by building friendship, faith, meaningful work and service. Courses also include a practical project in which students develop ideas to help their communities.
In short
- Nativity High has grown to 60 students since opening in 2024.
- The San Francisco school combines classical studies with prayer and uniforms.
- Its head expects enrolment to reach 100 next year.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters may see Nativity High’s growth as evidence that families value a distinctive education built around faith, demanding study, the arts and close relationships. Daily prayer, Latin, structured discussion and limits on devices can offer a coherent shared culture, while service projects and varied backgrounds may help students form friendships and connect learning with community life.
The case against
Critics may question whether a model centred on Catholic faith and traditional discipline is inclusive or suitable for all pupils, particularly in a diverse city. They may also ask whether reported demand and projected growth show that the approach can work at wider scale, and whether long journeys, fees or other practical barriers limit access despite the school’s varied intake.