Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
OpenAI says Apple’s trade secrets lawsuit is ‘rotten to its core’
OpenAI has filed a motion to dismiss Apple's trade secrets lawsuit, calling the allegations "meritless" and "rotten to its core." The ChatGPT maker argues Apple is mischaracterising former employees' actions as theft and labelling generic product development information as trade secrets, while failing to show it took reasonable steps to protect that information. The dispute matters because it pits two of the most powerful companies in tech against each other over AI talent and hardware development, following Apple's struggles to integrate AI into its own products.
Apple filed the original lawsuit in July, alleging that former staff who moved to OpenAI took confidential documents to aid its hardware plans. OpenAI's filing follows a blog post published on Tuesday and singles out ex-Apple employee Chang Liu, accused of downloading files after leaving, saying he was merely helping former colleagues who asked for assistance. OpenAI claims Apple is using the case to mask its own failures in retaining talent and developing AI products. A judge is due to hear arguments on the dismissal motion on 1 October, while Apple has separately requested a preliminary injunction, filed on Monday, to block OpenAI and the named employees from using any allegedly confidential material while the case proceeds.
In short
- OpenAI seeks dismissal of Apple's trade secrets lawsuit, calling it meritless
- Case centres on former Apple staff, including Chang Liu, now at OpenAI
- Dismissal hearing set for 1 October; Apple also seeks injunction
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Apple asserts that companies have a fundamental right to protect confidential information developed through significant investment, and that employees transferring proprietary documents to competitors shortly after departure represents the exact conduct trade secret law is designed to prevent. The alleged pattern of former Apple staff moving to OpenAI's hardware division, combined with specific instances of file downloads, suggests a systematic transfer of competitive advantage that threatens Apple's business interests and the integrity of the employment relationship.
The case against
OpenAI argues that Apple is mischaracterising routine assistance between former colleagues as theft, and conflating generic product information with genuine trade secrets deserving legal protection. The company contends that Apple has failed to demonstrate the rigorous safeguards required by law—such as clear access controls, explicit confidentiality agreements, or systematic monitoring—and is instead weaponising litigation to mask its own competitive shortcomings in AI and hardware development.
Explained simply
Trade secrets are confidential business information that a company takes steps to protect, such as technical plans or product designs. In this case, Apple says former employees took confidential documents with them when they joined OpenAI, which makes ChatGPT and is also developing hardware.
Apple’s lawsuit names former staff, including Chang Liu, and concerns information that Apple says could help OpenAI’s hardware plans. OpenAI disputes that account and says the information at issue is not protected trade secrets. The case matters because it raises questions about how companies protect sensitive information when employees move between rivals, and about competition for people with AI and hardware expertise.
AI Art Business Celebrity Companies Culture Entertainment Technology