Health news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Outrage as controversial signs bearing name of Robert E Lee that have been up for more than 100 years are set to be torn down
San Antonio’s Housing Trust wants to remove the rooftop “Hotel Robt E Lee” sign from a downtown building and replace it with lettering for its new name, Emerald on Travis. The proposal has upset residents who see the sign as both a long-standing city landmark and a reminder of Texas’s Confederate and pro-slavery history; it must be reviewed by the city’s Historic and Design Review Commission.
The 10-storey building was designed by local architect Herbert Green and opened as one of San Antonio’s first air-conditioned hotels. The sign dates to 1938, and a similar proposal to alter it was withdrawn nearly a decade ago after public opposition and resistance from the Conservation Society of San Antonio. The Trust also plans lobby improvements and a new lift, while retaining the “100% air-conditioned” sign.
In short
- San Antonio plans to replace a rooftop sign dating to 1938.
- Residents are divided over its history and landmark status.
- The city’s historic review commission must approve the proposal.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Removing the sign would avoid giving continued prominence to Robert E. Lee, a Confederate leader associated with the defence of slavery, and would let the building’s name reflect its present use. The proposed changes could also support the Housing Trust’s refurbishment while preserving other historic features, leaving the commission to weigh the sign’s significance as part of the building’s history.
The case against
The sign has marked a prominent San Antonio building for generations and is part of the story of an early air-conditioned hotel, so removing it would erase a visible historic feature. Keeping it, with interpretation that explains Lee’s place in Confederate and pro-slavery history, could preserve the city’s architectural record without endorsing the values the name represents.
Explained simply
Robert E Lee was a Confederate general during the American Civil War, fought from 1861 to 1865. The Confederacy was formed by southern states that left the United States, with the preservation of slavery central to their cause. Lee’s name remains a point of dispute in the United States because some people view Confederate names and memorials as heritage, while others see them as honours to a cause built on slavery.
The downtown San Antonio building was designed by local architect Herbert Green and opened as one of the city’s early air-conditioned hotels. Its rooftop sign dates from 1938, and a previous proposal to change it was withdrawn after public opposition. Changes to the building are considered by the city’s Historic and Design Review Commission, which reviews proposals affecting historic places.