Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Overrated Game’: GTA 6 PS5 Review Bombing Has Started After Record-Breaking Release
GTA 6 has received a wave of zero-rated user reviews on Metacritic, pulling its user score down to 5.4 despite a critics’ average of 99. The article says this gap matters because the Metacritic score can be affected by people who do not own the game, while purchase-verified ratings offer another indication of player response.
Many negative reviews cite the game’s 30 frames per second performance, its story or claims that the series has become “woke”; some raise specific objections to its life-simulation elements. The PlayStation Store rating is 4.84 from 170,000 reviews, and the article also reports that GTA 6 has sold a record 32.5 million copies.
In short
- Metacritic’s GTA 6 user score is 5.4 amid zero-rated reviews.
- Critics gave the game an average score of 99.
- The PlayStation Store rating is 4.84 from 170,000 reviews.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Critical reviews can reflect genuine disappointment: players may reasonably expect smoother performance from a major release, and may find the story or life-simulation elements less engaging than earlier games. User scores also give players a way to register views that critics’ averages may not capture, though the range of ratings and whether reviewers own the game affect how informative those scores are.
The case against
A wave of zero ratings may say more about coordinated score manipulation or culture-war reactions than about the experience of playing the game, particularly when some reviewers may not own it. Purchase-verified ratings and the game’s strong sales offer other evidence of player response, while complaints about performance or story are more useful when they explain specific shortcomings rather than simply assigning the lowest score.
Explained simply
Grand Theft Auto 6 is the latest game in Rockstar Games’ long-running open-world series, in which players explore a large fictional setting and follow a crime story. It is available on PlayStation 5, and its launch has drawn attention both for its sales and for sharply differing player ratings.
Metacritic publishes separate scores from professional critics and from users, whose reviews can be submitted without proof of purchase. The PlayStation Store also lets players rate games they have bought or accessed there, so its score reflects a different group of reviewers.
The disagreement matters because online ratings can shape how prospective players view a game, while large sales show how many people have bought it. Reviews raise different concerns, including performance and story, making the scores a broad snapshot rather than a single explanation of players’ reactions.