Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Oxford’s rabid pro-Jason Arday mob will silence any view that isn’t theirs
Protesters disrupted an event at the University of Oxford where academic Nathan Cofnas was due to speak, prompting an opinion writer to argue that attempts to stop controversial speakers undermine free expression. The article says universities should allow contested ideas to be heard and challenged through debate.
The writer reports that hundreds of demonstrators gathered on Tuesday, chanted against Cofnas and in support of the late Professor Jason Arday, and tried to prevent the event from going ahead. The article says doors were broken down, walls scaled, guests blocked and a police officer assaulted. Cofnas has accused Arday of plagiarism and holds disputed views about biological explanations for differences in human traits; the writer says those views can be challenged, while acknowledging disagreement over their scientific basis.
In short
- Protesters disrupted an Oxford talk by Nathan Cofnas.
- The writer argues controversial speakers should be challenged through debate.
- Cofnas’s claims about race and ability are disputed.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Universities should generally allow controversial speakers to present their arguments, since open debate gives students a chance to examine evidence, challenge claims and form their own judgements. Disrupting an event can prevent others from hearing or questioning ideas, and may create a precedent for silencing speakers through intimidation rather than argument.
The case against
A university is not obliged to treat every invitation as beyond criticism, particularly when a speaker’s claims about biological differences are disputed and his accusations against a late academic may be experienced as harmful or unfair. Protest can be a legitimate way to contest the platform an institution provides and to defend students’ ability to participate in an environment they regard as respectful; that case is strongest when protest avoids violence and coercion.
Explained simply
The University of Oxford is a university where speakers are sometimes invited to discuss contested academic and political questions. Such events can attract protest, particularly when a speaker’s claims are seen as harmful or poorly supported; universities must weigh the right to debate against the safety and access of those attending.
Nathan Cofnas is an academic whose views on biological explanations for differences between people have been disputed. He has also accused the late Professor Jason Arday of plagiarism, a claim that has become part of the disagreement around the event. Arday was a prominent scholar, and demonstrators chanted in his support.