Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Penn State tries to distance itself from campus lecture on ‘need to decolonize’ Holocaust museums following backlash
Penn State has sought to distance itself from a Jewish Studies Program lecture titled “Do we need to decolonize Holocaust museums?” after the event’s wording drew widespread criticism online. The university said it understood that the title had hurt members of its community, condemned antisemitism and stressed that a speaker’s presence on campus does not mean the university endorses their views.
The lecture, by Concordia University professor Erica Lehrer, examined museum ethics, including the care of objects taken from Jewish families and museums’ responsibilities when items have not been returned to survivors or descendants. Jewish Studies director Tommaso M. Milani said the discussion did not diminish the Holocaust or the importance of its museums and memorials. An Anti-Defamation League representative said the questions were important but that the term “decolonize” caused real pain beyond its academic context.
In short
- Penn State faced backlash over a lecture title about decolonising Holocaust museums.
- The talk examined museum collections and objects taken from Jewish families.
- The university said the speaker’s presence did not signal its endorsement.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the lecture’s framing can argue that museums should examine how they acquired and display objects taken from Jewish families, and whether they have met their responsibilities to survivors and descendants. In this view, asking whether museums should be “decolonized” is an academic prompt about ethics and institutional practice, not a claim that the Holocaust or its memorials matter less.
The case against
Critics can argue that applying “decolonize” to Holocaust museums risks importing a framework that obscures the Holocaust’s specific history and can sound as though its museums or commemorative purpose should be dismantled. Given the term’s political associations and the pain it caused in the Jewish community, they may see the title as needlessly hurtful even if the lecture itself raised legitimate questions about the return of stolen objects.
Explained simply
Holocaust museums and memorials preserve evidence of the Nazi genocide of six million Jews and honour those who were killed. Some also hold belongings taken from Jewish families during the Holocaust, raising questions about who should care for them and whether they should be returned to survivors or their descendants.
The lecture was organised by Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program and given by Erica Lehrer, a professor at Concordia University who studies museums and their ethics. Its title used “decolonize”, a term often used in debates about the legacy of colonialism; applying it to Holocaust museums prompted criticism and hurt among some people.
The dispute involves how museums should handle objects and address their history, as well as how language about the Holocaust is heard by different communities. Penn State said hosting a speaker does not mean it endorses their views, and the programme’s director said the discussion did not diminish the Holocaust or its memorials.