Health news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Police confirm investigation into claims patients died needlessly at ‘slaughterhouse hospital’
Police Scotland is investigating reports linked to several deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, after a surgeon alleged that patients died needlessly and that concerns were not acted on. The claims raise questions about patient safety, how NHS Grampian handled warnings and whether families were told that deaths may have been avoidable.
Consultant surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib, who has worked at NHS Grampian since 2014, says he formally raised concerns in 2021 and estimates that “dozens” of deaths may have been avoidable. He cited two patients who, he said, received the wrong operation and later died, and called for an investigation into possible corporate homicide. Police said a report was received in 2024 and that enquiries are under way, with a situational report to be sent to the Procurator Fiscal.
In short
- Police are investigating reports linked to several deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
- A surgeon alleges warnings about avoidable deaths were not acted on.
- NHS Grampian’s handling of the concerns is under scrutiny.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A thorough investigation is warranted because allegations of wrong operations, unheeded warnings and potentially avoidable deaths concern patients’ safety and families’ right to know. Examining what staff reported, how the health board responded and whether care fell below acceptable standards could establish accountability and help prevent similar harm.
The case against
The allegations remain claims under investigation, so it would be unfair to treat them as established failures or to imply criminal responsibility before the evidence is assessed. A careful process should test the surgeon’s account against records and other evidence, protect due process for staff and the health board, and avoid drawing conclusions that could undermine trust without substantiation.