Sport news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Police officer filmed punching man nine times in the head during arrest ‘when he tried to break into house’ is cleared of wrongdoing and will keep his job
PC Richard Williams has been cleared of misconduct allegations and will return to full duties following a five-day disciplinary hearing into an incident in May 2023. Williams was filmed restraining Steven Clark, a 34-year-old man attempting to break into a house on a housing estate in Porthmadog, North Wales, striking him repeatedly on the side of the head. The case attracted significant attention due to the visible force used and prompted both a disciplinary investigation and criminal trial at Caernarfon Crown Court, where Williams was found not guilty of assault and intentional strangulation.
Williams defended his actions as "distraction strikes" necessary to control a resisting suspect when he was unable to access his baton or Taser, stating he was concerned for his own safety and that of his colleagues. Clark, who had been reported as "off his head" on cannabis and amphetamines with a history of violent threats, testified that he was unable to breathe during the confrontation. The misconduct panel ruled that the nine allegations against Williams had not been proven, and the Independent Office for Police Conduct investigation, combined with the Crown Court proceedings, concluded the matter.
In short
- Officer cleared of misconduct in filmed arrest involving multiple head strikes
- Officer defended strikes as necessary "distraction" to control resisting suspect
- Both disciplinary and criminal processes concluded; officer returns to duty
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Williams’s supporters could argue that officers must be able to use proportionate force when restraining someone who is resisting, particularly if they believe colleagues or members of the public are at risk and cannot reach less-lethal equipment. A criminal jury acquitted him, and the misconduct panel found the allegations unproven, giving weight to the view that the evidence did not establish wrongdoing under the relevant standards.
The case against
Critics could argue that repeated blows to a person’s head carry a serious risk of injury and warrant close scrutiny, even during a difficult arrest. They may see the footage and Clark’s account that he could not breathe as grounds for concern about whether the force was necessary and proportionate, and argue that public confidence requires clear accountability when police use force.
Explained simply
Police officers in England and Wales may use force to arrest someone, but their actions can be examined in court and through a separate police disciplinary process. The Independent Office for Police Conduct investigates serious complaints and incidents involving the police.
In this case, officers were responding to an attempted break-in at a house in Porthmadog, North Wales. The force used during the arrest led to a criminal trial and a misconduct hearing, which consider different questions: whether a crime was committed and whether an officer’s conduct breached professional standards.
Cricket Entertainment Film Sport UK World