Marvel's Wolverine has proven divisive since its release one week ago, with critics divided and social media generally unfavourable, yet the game maintains a strong user score on the PlayStation Store. Push Square has organised a poll to gauge how players rate the experience, reflecting broader interest in understanding the game's reception across different audiences.

The game has achieved a Metacritic score of 76 from 134 reviews, making it one of the lowest-scoring PlayStation 5 exclusives to date. Push Square's own reviewer awarded it 8/10, commending its visuals, character performances and location variety. Player comments reveal mixed experiences, with some praising the storytelling and combat mechanics whilst others cite concerns about ability cooldown timings, occasional glitches and relatively short campaign length (reported as 12–21 hours by various players).