Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Producer sues Travis Scott, Don Toliver, and Sony Music, claiming he owns half the master of JackBoys track ‘What To Do?’
Producer Niv Kalisky, who works as Early Yellow, is suing Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sony Music and other defendants over the JackBoys track “What To Do?”. He alleges the recording uses his earlier work without proper payment and is asking a New York federal court to recognise him as a 50% owner of the track’s master recording and award him at least half its earnings.
Kalisky says he emailed his recording “Moazin99bpm” to people connected with producers London Cyr and Jenius in 2019, and that a beat incorporating it was later used in the track. The complaint points to more than 270 million Spotify streams and 60 million YouTube plays, and says the instrumental elements are identical apart from the artists’ vocals. After Kalisky sought payment and later filed takedown notices, Sony and Epic challenged them; the track was reinstated on several services. These are allegations in a lawsuit, which also names Sheck Wes, producers Mike Dean, London Cyr and Jenius, and several record companies.
In short
- Niv Kalisky claims “What To Do?” uses his recording without paying master royalties.
- He is seeking 50% ownership and at least half the recording’s earnings.
- The complaint cites over 270 million Spotify streams and 60 million YouTube plays.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
If Kalisky’s account is supported by the evidence, his recording was incorporated into a commercially successful track without proper permission or compensation. Recognising a substantial share of the master could protect contributors whose work is used in a release and ensure that earnings reflect their creative contribution.
The case against
The defendants may dispute that Kalisky’s recording was used, that any use was unauthorised, or that it gives him a 50% ownership interest in the master. Similarities between instrumental elements and the track’s success alone may not establish those claims; the court will need to assess the evidence, any permissions or agreements, and the parties’ respective contributions.
Explained simply
A master recording is the finished recorded version of a song, and its owner can earn money when it is played or sold. A producer helps create a track’s music and sound; several producers and performers may work on the same recording.
Early Yellow is the working name of producer Niv Kalisky. He says a recording he sent to people connected with producers London Cyr and Jenius was later used in “What To Do?”, a song on the JackBoys release involving Travis Scott and Don Toliver.
The case also involves Sony Music, Epic and other artists, producers and record companies. The dispute matters because it concerns who owns the recording and is entitled to its income, and how music-makers should be credited and paid when their work is used.
Entertainment Music Trending Weird & Viral