Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Public support for Rosebank depends on lower energy bills – as Burnham faces Labour ‘civil war’ on drilling
A Survation poll suggests public support for drilling in the Rosebank North Sea oil and gas field rests heavily on the expectation that it will lower household energy bills. Former Labour donor Dale Vince says that expectation is a “false promise”, warning that support could fade if bills do not fall; the issue is also exposing deep divisions within Andy Burnham’s Labour team.
The poll of 2,011 UK adults found 52 per cent support approving Rosebank and 19 per cent oppose it. Among the 35 per cent who believe approval would lower their bills, 73 per cent support drilling; among everyone else, support is 41 per cent and opposition 23 per cent. Vince and Rosebank’s majority owner, Equinor, say the oil would be sold at international market prices, while Labour MPs are reportedly split, with around 100 strongly against and 100 strongly in favour.
In short
- Rosebank support is closely tied to hopes of lower energy bills.
- The poll found 52 per cent support drilling and 19 per cent oppose it.
- Labour MPs are reportedly divided over whether to approve the field.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters argue that developing Rosebank could strengthen domestic energy production, provide jobs and tax revenue, and reduce reliance on imports. The poll indicates that many people favour approval, especially those who expect it to ease household bills, and supporters may see those benefits as worthwhile even amid uncertainty about how global prices affect bills.
The case against
Opponents argue that Rosebank’s oil would be sold at international prices, so drilling cannot be relied on to lower household bills; presenting it that way risks misleading the public. They also cite climate and energy-transition concerns, and argue that investment should instead accelerate cleaner energy that can offer more durable security and affordability.