RedZone host Scott Hanson defends NFL officiating, calls league ‘best officiated’ in America
NFL RedZone host Scott Hanson has defended the standard of NFL officiating, calling it the best among America’s four major sports leagues. His view matters amid fan concerns about frequent penalties and disputed calls early in the 2026 season.
An ESPN Insights report found more accepted penalties through Week 4 than in any comparable period since 1978, and 17 touchdowns had been nullified, up from five at the same point last season. The NFL said penalties per game were down this year; Hanson argued that accuracy matters more than the number of flags, and said human limits can lead to mistakes. He also questioned whether officials call playoff games differently and said he would support publishing officials’ performance grades.
- Scott Hanson called NFL officiating the best among major US sports.
- Penalties and overturned touchdowns have risen early in the season.
- He says accuracy matters more than the number of flags.
New here? Start with this
The NFL is the United States’ top professional American football league, and its matches are overseen by on-field officials who enforce rules on contact, scoring and player conduct. Penalties can cost a team ground or cancel a play, so calls often have a direct effect on a match.
Fans and teams scrutinise officiating because decisions can be difficult to make in fast-moving situations, and mistakes can influence results. The NFL is one of America’s four major sports leagues, alongside the NBA, MLB and NHL; comparisons of officiating standards are difficult because each sport has different rules and demands.
The league reviews officials’ work, while proposals such as making performance grades public raise questions about transparency and how individual calls should be assessed. Disputes over officiating matter to supporters’ trust in the fairness of competition.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Hanson’s defence rests on accuracy and consistency: more penalties or overturned touchdowns do not by themselves show that officials are doing a worse job if they are correctly enforcing the rules. The NFL says penalties per game are down, and human judgement inevitably leaves room for mistakes; publishing performance grades could help make standards more transparent.
The case against
The rise in accepted penalties and nullified touchdowns may suggest that officiating is having an unusually large effect on games, whether through inconsistent calls, overly strict enforcement or unclear rules. Fans can reasonably want stronger evidence that decisions are fair and consistent, including across regular-season and playoff games, before accepting claims that the league is the best officiated.