Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Revealed: Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are largest CO2 exporters of all time
Carbon Brief analysis finds Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are the largest fossil-fuel exporters of CO₂ emissions since 1850, when responsibility is assigned to the country where fuels are extracted. The approach highlights how exported coal, oil and gas add to the historical warming attributed to producer nations, including Australia, which faces pressure over continued fossil-fuel expansion ahead of the UN climate summit it is co-president of.
The analysis, based on data compiled by CICERO researcher Robbie Andrew, says fossil-fuel exports have carried hundreds of billions of tonnes of CO₂ abroad over 175 years. Including exports more than doubles Australia’s warming contribution and increases Saudi Arabia’s by more than four times. The US and China still rank highest under this accounting, while Russia remains third; other major exporters include Venezuela, Iran, Norway, the United Arab Emirates and Canada.
In short
- Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia lead historical fossil-fuel export emissions.
- Counting exports more than doubles Australia’s warming contribution.
- The US and China still rank highest under extraction-based accounting.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Assigning emissions to the country that extracts and exports fossil fuels recognises that producers enable combustion abroad and profit from supplying it. Including these exported emissions can therefore give a fuller picture of historical responsibility and help inform expectations for countries expanding production, especially where they have benefited from export revenues and have capacity to act.
The case against
Assigning exported emissions to producers can overstate their responsibility for carbon burned elsewhere, since importing countries chose to use the fuels and often gained economic benefit from doing so. A fair account could instead place emissions with the countries where combustion occurred, or share responsibility between producers and consumers, while recognising that historical data and national accounting choices affect the rankings.
Explained simply
Fossil fuels such as coal, oil and gas release carbon dioxide when they are burned, adding to global warming. They are often extracted in one country and burned in another, so estimates of each country’s contribution can differ depending on whether emissions are counted where the fuel is produced or where it is used.
This analysis assigns emissions from exported fuels to the country they came from, as well as counting emissions from fuels used at home. It draws on historical data going back to 1850, when large-scale fossil-fuel production began, and includes countries such as Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia among the major exporters.
The accounting helps explain why fossil-fuel-producing countries face questions about their role in climate change, even when much of their fuel is burned abroad. Australia is also a co-president of the upcoming UN climate summit, putting its fossil-fuel policies in focus.
Climate Europe Government Middle East Politics Science World