News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Review says new laws should protect infrastructure
A review commissioned by South Yorkshire Mayor Oliver Coppard has recommended new legislation allowing public authorities to purchase major privately-owned infrastructure threatened with closure, in a move prompted by the 2022 closure of Doncaster Sheffield Airport. The South Yorkshire Strategic Infrastructure Inquiry, chaired by Martin McKervey, concluded that where the loss of a major asset would cause "damaging, harmful and detrimental" economic impact, the government should be able to intervene, since such closures can badly harm local communities and economies.
The report proposes granting local authorities, regional governments or national bodies the power to temporarily halt a closure or sale to allow an impact assessment, alongside a statutory right to buy the asset at market value through a simplified compulsory purchase order if the owner refuses to sell voluntarily. Doncaster Sheffield Airport shut in 2022 after owner Peel Group said it was no longer economically viable; the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority has since approved £160m to help reopen it, with costs projected to reach £193m. The inquiry, which also examined water and energy infrastructure, additionally called for a national Regional Aviation Strategy to help local authorities pool resources and support vulnerable regional airports.
In short
- Review urges new laws to let authorities buy threatened infrastructure assets
- Prompted by Doncaster Sheffield Airport's 2022 closure
- Report also calls for a national regional aviation strategy
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Advocates for intervention powers argue that major infrastructure closures create cascading economic damage to communities that have few alternatives, and that assets like regional airports serve essential connectivity functions whose value extends beyond pure profitability calculations. They contend that temporary halt periods for impact assessment and options to purchase at fair market value represent proportionate safeguards that respect legitimate property rights whilst protecting broader public interests, particularly where a single closure can destabilise employment, investment, and regional competitiveness for decades. Coordinated regional strategies, they suggest, would allow struggling but essential airports to benefit from pooled resources and support.
The case against
Opponents argue that private ownership must entail genuine exit rights, and that legislation requiring government purchase options effectively nationalises losses whilst shielding unsuccessful ventures from market discipline. They contend that profitability constraints often reflect real economic constraints—if an airport cannot sustain passenger demand or operational costs, state intervention merely postpones closure whilst deploying public resources that could serve other priorities more effectively. Such powers, critics warn, risk establishing ongoing subsidisation of inefficient operations and set problematic precedent for state override of commercial decisions across multiple sectors.
Explained simply
Major infrastructure includes facilities such as airports, water networks and energy supplies that support jobs and everyday services. These assets may be privately owned, so decisions to close or sell them can affect people and businesses well beyond the owner.
Doncaster Sheffield Airport closed in 2022 after its owner, Peel Group, said it was no longer economically viable. The South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority has since approved public funding to help reopen it, and the inquiry considered what could happen when other important infrastructure is at risk.
The inquiry was commissioned by South Yorkshire Mayor Oliver Coppard and chaired by Martin McKervey. Its recommendations concern whether public bodies should be able to step in when an asset’s loss could seriously affect a local economy, and how regional airports might be supported.