Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ryan Murphy’s ‘American Horror Story’ Replacement Is Officially a Streaming Hit
Ryan Murphy's new FX horror-thriller *The Shards* has become a streaming success, ranking within the top ten most-watched shows on Disney's platforms after four weeks of new episodes. The 1980s-set series, based on Bret Easton Ellis' novel of the same name, follows a group of teenagers whose lives are upended by a mysterious new student, blending the anthology horror style of Murphy's *American Horror Story* with the dark, stylish teen-drama sensibility of *Euphoria*. Its streaming performance marks a notable early win for FX, even as critical and audience reception remains mixed.
The show currently ranks third globally on Disney+ and fifth on Hulu, according to FlixPatrol, having slipped from the number one spot it held at launch as other titles, such as *Furious*, have overtaken it. Reviews have been polarised: the first season holds a 56% critic score and a 44% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, with some critics, including those at Collider and ScreenRant, calling the adaptation surprisingly restrained or "sanitised" compared with the shocking source material, while others, such as CBR, have praised it as masterful. New episodes air on FX on Wednesdays at 9pm, streaming on Hulu in the US and Disney+ internationally, with the season finale scheduled for 9 September.
In short
- Ryan Murphy's *The Shards* is a top-ten streaming hit on Disney+ and Hulu
- Based on Bret Easton Ellis' novel, set in the 1980s
- Reviews are polarised despite strong viewership; finale airs 9 September
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The show’s strong streaming rankings suggest it has found a substantial audience, and its blend of horror and teen drama may offer a distinctive, accessible take on the source novel. A more restrained adaptation can also be defended as a deliberate choice that lets the characters and atmosphere carry the story rather than relying on shock.
The case against
The rankings measure viewing rather than whether the series succeeds artistically, and its mixed audience and critic scores suggest it has not persuaded everyone. Viewers who value the novel’s disturbing edge may reasonably feel that sanitising its material weakens the adaptation, while the show’s early peak followed by a slide in the charts makes its staying power uncertain.
Explained simply
Ryan Murphy is a television producer known for series including American Horror Story, which tells a different horror story each season. The Shards is an FX drama based on a novel by Bret Easton Ellis, set in 1980s Los Angeles and centred on teenagers unsettled by the arrival of a new student.
FX is part of Disney’s television business, and its shows are available through Hulu in the United States and Disney+ in many other countries. The Shards combines horror with teen drama, and its reception has been divided, making its popularity with streaming viewers a separate measure of how well it has performed.