Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Saba’s Weinstein: I’ve made £1.2bn for ‘Mom and Pop’ investment trust shareholders
Saba Capital founder Boaz Weinstein said his campaign against UK investment trusts has generated £1.2bn for mainly small investors over the past two years. He argued that Saba’s activism and purchases have helped lift the wider sector, prompting more share buybacks and attention to trusts whose shares traded below the value of their holdings.
Weinstein described investment trusts as outdated and said Saba had been among the few buyers of their shares. Its campaigns have helped bring about Smithson’s conversion into an open-ended fund and the replacement of the boards at Edinburgh Worldwide and Impax Environmental Markets. Saba recently failed to install its nominees at Baillie Gifford’s US Growth Trust, while Weinstein accused Baillie Gifford of damaging value; the firm’s assets under management fell from £336bn five years ago to £196bn, he said.
In short
- Weinstein says Saba’s campaigns created £1.2bn for investors.
- Saba has won several investment trust battles.
- He criticised Baillie Gifford over falling assets and losses.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Weinstein’s strongest case is that investment trusts trading below the value of their holdings can leave shareholders with value unrealised, and that an active buyer willing to challenge boards can help narrow those discounts. He says Saba’s campaigns have prompted buybacks and scrutiny across the sector, benefiting small investors, while changes at several trusts show that persistent engagement can bring reform where existing boards have not acted.
The case against
The strongest case against Saba’s approach is that pressure from an activist investor may favour quick changes or outcomes that suit its own investment strategy, rather than the long-term interests of all shareholders. Investment trusts can offer a distinct structure and investment mandate, and replacing boards or converting a trust may disrupt those aims; claims about gains for small investors and benefits to the wider sector also need to be assessed against evidence beyond Weinstein’s own account.
Explained simply
Investment trusts are listed companies that invest in shares and other assets on behalf of their shareholders. Their share price can trade below the value of the investments they hold, a gap known as a discount; trusts can try to narrow it through measures such as buying back shares.
Saba Capital is an investment firm founded by Boaz Weinstein. It has bought shares in several UK trusts and campaigned for changes to how some are run, including board changes and a move by Smithson to become an open-ended fund, where investors buy and sell units through the fund.
These campaigns have brought Saba into disagreement with trust boards and investment managers, including Baillie Gifford. The debate matters to shareholders because changes to a trust’s structure, management or share-buyback policy can affect the value and liquidity of their holdings.