World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Scheana Shay gives heartbreaking reason she’s considering having baby No. 2
Scheana Shay said she and her husband, Brock Davies, have been discussing whether to have a second child. After attending a friend’s father’s funeral and seeing the friend supported by two siblings, Shay said she wants their daughter, Summer, to have someone alongside her when a loved one dies. She is considering the idea, but says she is not ready to take the next step.
Shay, 41, and Davies, 36, welcomed Summer in April 2021; she is currently in what Shay describes as an only-child phase and does not want to share her mother. Shay has previously said she developed HELLP syndrome during pregnancy, a serious complication, and that a second child might involve surrogacy. In 2025, she said she was still coming to terms with that possibility and worried she might not feel the same connection to a baby born through a surrogate.
In short
- Scheana Shay is weighing whether to have a second child.
- She wants daughter Summer to have a sibling for support.
- A future pregnancy may involve surrogacy after HELLP syndrome.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A sibling could offer Summer companionship and emotional support through family losses and other difficult moments, as Shay saw at her friend’s funeral. Having another child may also create a lasting family bond, even if the decision involves uncertainty and a different path to pregnancy.
The case against
A second child should be wanted for their own sake, rather than chiefly to provide future support for Summer, since siblings’ relationships and circumstances cannot be guaranteed. Shay’s serious pregnancy complication and her unresolved feelings about surrogacy are substantial reasons to take time and consider what is right for her and her family.