Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Second Amendment as a Right to Sell Guns as Well as to Have and Buy Them?
A Fifth Circuit panel ruled that the Second Amendment’s text covers the commercial sale of firearms, vacating a lower court decision that had rejected Jeremiah Deare’s challenge to federal licensing and record-keeping rules. The case will return to the district court for further proceedings, so the ruling does not finally decide whether the requirements are constitutional.
Deare was indicted for conspiring to deal firearms without a federal licence and for making false statements in licensed dealers’ records. The panel said the right to keep and bear arms implies a right to purchase them, and noted that the government accepted that the amendment applies to commercial sales. The article says the decision appears not to affect the false-statements charge; the supplied text ends during a separate concurrence.
In short
- Fifth Circuit says the Second Amendment covers firearm sales.
- Deare’s challenge returns to the district court.
- The ruling does not settle the rules’ constitutionality.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Because the right to keep and bear arms would be difficult to exercise without access to firearms, its protection can reasonably be understood to include buying and selling them. Treating ordinary commercial sales as within the amendment’s scope would require courts to assess licensing and record-keeping rules on their merits, rather than excluding them at the outset.
The case against
The amendment protects keeping and bearing arms, but that does not necessarily make every activity in the firearms trade a constitutional right. Congress may reasonably regulate commercial dealing through licences and records to support oversight and enforcement, while leaving lawful access to firearms intact; recognising sales as covered by the amendment could make such safeguards harder to sustain.
Explained simply
The Second Amendment to the US Constitution protects the right to keep and bear arms. Courts have also considered how that right relates to buying firearms and to the rules governing businesses that sell them.
Federal law requires many people who deal firearms as a business to obtain a licence and keep records of sales. Jeremiah Deare was charged with dealing firearms without a licence and with making false statements in dealers’ records.
The Fifth Circuit is a federal appeals court covering several southern US states. Its ruling concerns whether the right to bear arms covers commercial sales; the case now returns to a lower court, which will continue considering Deare’s challenge to the licensing and record-keeping rules.