World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Serial conman tricked sheriff into cancelling £11,700 compensation bill by cashing in on HMRC blunder… and now he’s facing jail
Derek Foster, a 53-year-old former taxman from Perth, was found guilty of fraud after misleading a sheriff into cancelling an £11,700 compensation order. He used an HMRC administrative error to support a false claim that he had repaid the money, avoiding further punishment under a community payback order.
Foster had originally been ordered to repay the sum after a 2019 conviction for swindling the Inland Revenue. Although he presented an HMRC letter saying the debt was paid in 2022, investigators later found he had paid nothing. Sheriff Peter Hammond said custody was the court’s leading option; sentencing was deferred for reports.
In short
- Foster was convicted of fraud over an unpaid £11,700 compensation bill.
- An HMRC administrative error helped him persuade a sheriff the debt was paid.
- The sheriff warned that custody was being considered.
Explained simply
A compensation order is a court instruction to repay money, often after a criminal conviction. A community payback order is a sentence served in the community, which can include unpaid work or other requirements.
HMRC is the UK body that collects taxes and administers some payments. Its records and letters can be used as evidence about a tax debt, but an administrative error does not itself mean that money has been repaid.
The case concerns Derek Foster, who was convicted in 2019 of swindling the Inland Revenue and ordered to repay £11,700. The alleged false claim about repayment matters because it led a sheriff to cancel that order, affecting both the amount owed and the punishment being served.