World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Russell Brand considers appeal after dismissing trial barrister
Russell Brand is considering appealing his convictions for raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others, as well as his sentence of ten years and six months. He has dismissed Ian Winter KC, who represented him at trial, and asked other lawyers to assess whether there are grounds to challenge the verdict or sentence.
Winter has faced criticism for remarks to a journalist after the verdict and for a closing argument that invoked rape myths; he has referred himself to the Bar Standards Board. Brand’s defence also raised concerns about late disclosure of evidence, which the judge considered not particularly significant. Legal sources say the jury’s mixed verdicts, including acquittals on two rape charges and attempted indecent assault, could make an appeal harder; no decision to lodge one has been made.
In short
- Brand is considering an appeal against his convictions and sentence.
- He has dismissed his trial barrister, Ian Winter KC.
- Legal sources say the jury’s mixed verdicts may complicate an appeal.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
An appeal could be justified if the trial involved a material legal error, unfair handling of evidence or a sentence that was wrongly assessed; the right to challenge a conviction is an important safeguard, especially given the consequences. Brand’s new lawyers may be able to assess those questions independently, including the defence’s concerns about disclosure and the conduct of the trial.
The case against
An appeal should not be pursued merely because the outcome is unwelcome: it needs a sound legal basis, and the judge considered the late disclosure concerns not particularly significant. The jury’s mixed verdicts suggest it assessed the individual charges separately, and a lengthy trial has already tested the evidence, so overturning the convictions or sentence may be difficult.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Shameless Russell Brand wants to appeal his rape and sexual assault convictions as he begins 10-year stint behind bars – after sacking lawyer who exploded at journalist outside court”.