World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
SJSU volleyball coach’s assault allegations prompt responses by current and former employers
SJSU says it cannot investigate a former Fairfield volleyball player’s allegation that Todd Kress physically assaulted her in a hotel room in 1998, because the alleged incident took place at another institution before he joined SJSU. Fairfield has condemned sexual misconduct but declined to comment on specific cases. The correspondence and statements bring renewed attention to how the universities have handled the allegation.
SJSU said it reviewed the complaint and had previously discussed the possibility of a formal process through Fairfield with the player’s lawyer. It did not say whether Kress was interviewed, whether his account was corroborated or whether any safety measures followed. Fairfield did not disclose whether it investigated the allegation; Kress was contacted for comment. The report also notes a recent lawsuit by former SJSU associate head coach Melissa Batie-Smoose, who alleges intimidation, harassment and retaliation.
In short
- SJSU says the 1998 allegation falls outside its investigative authority.
- Fairfield condemned sexual misconduct but did not discuss the case.
- The report gives no details on whether either university investigated.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Universities have a responsibility to take allegations of serious misconduct seriously, including by explaining what steps they can take and whether concerns about current safety have been addressed. The limited information disclosed by SJSU and Fairfield leaves legitimate questions about whether the allegation was investigated and how the institutions support people who report misconduct.
The case against
The allegation concerns an incident said to have occurred in 1998 at Fairfield, before Kress joined SJSU, so SJSU may lack the authority or evidence needed to conduct a meaningful investigation into it. Fairness also requires distinguishing an allegation from an established finding, and institutions should avoid public comment on specific cases where privacy, due process or an incomplete record may constrain what they can responsibly say.
Explained simply
San José State University (SJSU) and Fairfield University are both involved because the allegation concerns an incident said to have happened when Todd Kress was at Fairfield, before he became SJSU’s volleyball coach. A former Fairfield player alleges that Kress assaulted her in a hotel room in 1998; the allegation is not, by itself, a finding that he did so.
The universities’ roles matter because the allegation concerns conduct at one institution and a later job at another. Their responses raise questions about what each can examine and what steps, if any, were taken. A separate lawsuit by former SJSU associate head coach Melissa Batie-Smoose, which includes allegations of intimidation, harassment and retaliation, adds to the scrutiny of the university’s handling of workplace complaints.