Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Skylar Grey hits out at Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers’ ‘rock’ Grammy nominations
Skylar Grey criticised the Grammys for nominating Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers in rock categories, questioning whether the awards reflect what rock music is. Her social media post adds to wider criticism of this year’s nominations and how genres are represented.
Both artists received two nods across Best Rock Song and Best Rock Performance: Bridgers for “Lost Boys” and Rodrigo for “What’s Wrong With Me”, recorded with Robert Smith. Grey’s video compared those tracks with Motionless In White’s “R.I.P.”, on which she features. Electronic musician John Summit also criticised the nominations, saying the dance categories overlooked club music and DJs.
In short
- Skylar Grey questioned the Grammys’ rock nominations.
- Bridgers and Rodrigo each received two rock nods.
- John Summit also criticised the electronic music shortlists.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Genre categories should reflect recognisable musical traditions, so critics can reasonably argue that rock nominations ought to prioritise the sound and practices associated with rock. If tracks by artists better known for other styles are nominated while rock acts such as Motionless In White are overlooked, that may suggest the category is being applied inconsistently and that its boundaries deserve scrutiny.
The case against
Rock has never had a fixed boundary, and artists from different backgrounds can make work that draws meaningfully on its sound or tradition. Grammy voters may judge the nominated songs on their own merits rather than the artists’ usual genres, while category decisions inevitably involve difficult distinctions; a different view of those choices does not by itself show that rock has been misrepresented.
Explained simply
The Grammys divide awards into genres such as rock and dance, though music can cross those boundaries. The categories recognise recordings and performances, rather than defining what all music in a genre must sound like.
Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers are singer-songwriters whose work spans pop and rock, while Skylar Grey has also worked across different styles. Grammy nominations can shape how music is promoted and discussed, so choices about genre categories often prompt debate among artists and listeners.