Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
UK Government urges SNP to improve opportunities for Scotland’s out-of-work young people
The UK Government has urged ministers in Scotland to work with it to improve opportunities for young people who are not in work, education or training. The call follows a review by Alan Milburn, which says the problem affects the whole UK and proposes earlier support and clearer routes into jobs and training.
A PwC index puts Scotland’s NEET rate at 16 per cent, higher than any other UK region; Labour says that represents about 90,000 young people. Milburn recommends measures across education, health and welfare, including a guaranteed job for eligible young people unemployed for 18 months. Some benefit changes would not automatically apply in Scotland because relevant powers are devolved, and the review says each devolved government should adapt its approach to its own services.
In short
- Scotland has the UK’s highest reported rate of young people outside work, education or training.
- The UK Government wants Scottish ministers to work with it on support and opportunities.
- Devolved powers mean some recommendations would need a Scottish approach.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The UK Government has a reasonable case for urging joint action: Scotland’s reported NEET rate is the highest in the UK, and prolonged disconnection from work or education can limit young people’s prospects and widen inequalities. Earlier, coordinated support across education, health and welfare, alongside a job guarantee for eligible young people, could offer clearer routes into training and employment.
The case against
Scottish ministers could reasonably argue that policy should be shaped around Scotland’s devolved powers and services, as the review itself recognises, rather than follow a UK-wide model. A job guarantee and benefit-related measures may need careful adaptation to local needs and resources, while a public call to act risks obscuring work already under way or turning a shared challenge into a political dispute.
Explained simply
In the UK, young people are often described as NEET if they are not in a job, education or training. The term covers people in different circumstances, including those seeking work and those who may need extra support to take part in learning or employment.
Education, health and some welfare services are devolved, so the Scottish Government has responsibility for areas that the UK Government controls elsewhere. The two governments may therefore need to work together, while adapting support to the services and powers available in Scotland.
The issue matters because time spent outside work or learning can affect young people’s future opportunities. A review led by Alan Milburn argues that support should start earlier and that routes into jobs and training should be clearer.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “SNP warned to tackle Scotland’s NEETs crisis… but minister says she doesn’t even like the term!”.