New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Spiritbox’s Courtney LaPlante defends ejecting “old drunk man punching people in the head” from gig after online criticism
Spiritbox singer Courtney LaPlante has defended her decision to halt a gig in Phoenix, Arizona, and have a fan ejected after he was seen punching other audience members, following online criticism suggesting she had thrown someone out simply for moshing. LaPlante said drummer Zev Rose spotted the man hitting people who were facing the stage in the VIP pit, and that security had already been alerted to him three times before the show was stopped, making it "the final straw". The episode highlights the tension bands face between allowing rough crowd behaviour typical of metal gigs and stepping in when it tips into genuine violence.
The incident happened on 15 July 2026 during Spiritbox's support slot for Evanescence, alongside Nova Twins, at the Talking Stick Resort Amphitheatre. LaPlante stopped the show before its closing song, ‘Soft Spine’, telling the crowd she wouldn't continue until security identified the man, whom she later described as an "old drunk man". After facing criticism on X from fans who felt the article's lack of detail made her look intolerant of hardcore dancing, LaPlante clarified the full context in a series of posts, insisting she had no regrets about intervening.
In short
- Spiritbox's Courtney LaPlante halted a Phoenix gig to eject a violent fan.
- She says he punched multiple audience members in the VIP pit.
- LaPlante defended the move online after backlash over article's vague wording.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A performer has a responsibility to protect the audience, and deliberately punching people who are facing the stage goes beyond the rough, consensual contact some fans expect at a metal gig. If security had already been alerted several times, stopping the show to ensure the reported violence was addressed was a proportionate way to prioritise people’s safety.
The case against
Crowd movement and physical dancing can be part of metal shows, so ejecting someone risks treating consensual moshing as misconduct if the behaviour is not clearly established. Critics may also argue that stopping a set and publicly identifying a fan based on limited information can invite unfair judgement; clear, consistent evidence and security procedures matter when distinguishing violence from ordinary pit behaviour.
Explained simply
Spiritbox is a Canadian heavy metal band. In July 2026, singer Courtney LaPlante stopped a concert in Phoenix, Arizona and had a fan removed from the audience after he was seen punching other people. The incident became disputed online, with some suggesting the fan had been ejected for simply moshing, the vigorous and physical dancing common at metal concerts, rather than for genuine violence.
The full circumstances were that the man had repeatedly punched audience members in the VIP pit, and security had already warned him three times before LaPlante halted the performance. The episode highlights an ongoing tension in live music, particularly within the heavy metal scene, between accepting the rough physicality that typically characterises such gigs and intervening when behaviour becomes genuinely violent.
The incident raises questions about where venues and artists should draw the line on crowd behaviour. How to balance preserving the intensity that attracts fans to metal shows whilst protecting attendees from harm remains a challenge for those organising live music events.