World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home review – Kirk, Spock and co on semi-intentionally hilarious save-the-whale mission
The Guardian reviews the 40th-anniversary rerelease of Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, directed by Leonard Nimoy, calling it the silliest yet most enjoyably absurd instalment of the franchise. The Enterprise crew, in disgrace after events of the previous film, must travel back in time to 1986 San Francisco to retrieve humpback whales in order to answer an alien probe threatening 23rd-century Earth, a premise the reviewer finds gleefully ridiculous rather than convincing science fiction.
The film opens with a dedication to the crew of the space shuttle Challenger, which exploded that year, and glosses over the death of Kirk's son from the prior instalment with striking casualness. Highlights singled out include the crew's fish-out-of-water antics on the streets of San Francisco, a comic exchange between Kirk and Spock about 20th-century vulgarity, and a scene of Spock swimming ecstatically with the whales. Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home returns to UK and Irish cinemas from 4 September.
In short
- Star Trek IV rereleased in UK/Irish cinemas for its 40th anniversary
- Crew time-travel to 1986 San Francisco to save whales
- Reviewer calls it absurd but preposterously good fun
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The film’s knowingly absurd whale-rescue plot and fish-out-of-water comedy can be seen as a welcome change of pace, letting the crew’s warmth and ingenuity carry an entertaining story rather than demanding scientific plausibility. Its dedication to the Challenger crew and concern for endangered whales also give the comic adventure an earnest humane thread.
The case against
The same comic approach may feel too slight for a story that invokes both the Challenger disaster and the serious loss of Kirk’s son, treating the latter with conspicuous ease. Viewers seeking the franchise’s weightier science fiction may find the implausible premise and broad humour weaken the emotional and dramatic stakes.
Explained simply
Star Trek is a science-fiction series about the crew of a starship called the Enterprise, led by Captain James T Kirk. Spock, the ship’s half-human, half-Vulcan science officer, is among its best-known characters. The Voyage Home is the fourth film in the original series of films, directed by Leonard Nimoy, who also played Spock.
The story follows the crew after the events of the previous film, when they have fallen out of favour with their authorities. They travel from the 23rd century to 1986 San Francisco, where they need to find humpback whales to respond to a mysterious threat to Earth. The film mixes space adventure with comedy about the crew encountering everyday life in the past.
Americas Art Celebrity Culture Entertainment Film Geopolitics Paranormal Politics Travel Weird & Viral World