Strictly’s new presenters – after frosty reviews have they warmed up?
Strictly Come Dancing’s new presenting trio received a mixed response when they debuted a month ago, prompting questions about whether the BBC’s flagship Saturday night show had found a workable replacement for Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman. Critics say Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe and Johannes Radebe are gradually settling into their different roles, though some concerns remain about the show’s pace and chemistry.
Willis and Widdicombe present the live shows together, while Radebe interviews celebrities after their dances from the mezzanine. Commentators say Widdicombe has become more comfortable, but his spontaneous comic style can feel rushed in brief exchanges with judges; they also suggest the pair rely visibly on scripts and gags. The article notes that ratings have dipped, but gives no figures.
In short
- Strictly’s new presenters drew a mixed reception.
- Critics say the trio are slowly settling in.
- Josh Widdicombe’s comic style remains a concern.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The trio are still early in their run, and settling into a long-established live format can take time; signs that Widdicombe is becoming more comfortable suggest the presenting may grow more assured. Willis and Widdicombe bring different styles, while Radebe’s interviews add a distinct role, so allowing the team time to develop could help the show find a fresh rhythm.
The case against
A flagship live show depends on easy chemistry and well-paced exchanges, and the reported reliance on scripts and rushed moments with the judges may make the presentation feel less natural. With ratings said to have dipped and concerns about pace still unresolved, viewers and the BBC have reason to question whether the new arrangement is working well enough.