World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Susan Smith prosecutor fears her release would put her in grieving father’s face ‘every day’
Susan Smith, who is serving a life sentence for killing her two young sons, is due to face a South Carolina parole board. The prosecutor who secured her conviction says her release could bring renewed social media attention and distress the boys’ father, David Smith, who continues to seek justice for them.
Michael, aged three, and 14-month-old Alexander died when Smith drove her car into a lake on 25 October 1994. She initially told police that a carjacker had taken the children, but was convicted of two murders in 1995; under the law at the time, she became eligible for parole after 30 years. She was denied parole at her first hearing in November 2024, and prosecutor Tommy Pope says he will attend future hearings with David Smith.
In short
- Susan Smith is seeking parole after serving 30 years.
- Her prosecutor says release could distress the boys’ father.
- Smith was denied parole at her first hearing in 2024.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The murders were exceptionally grave, and the children’s father may face renewed grief and public attention if Smith is released. A parole board could reasonably weigh the continuing impact on him and the community, alongside the need to protect the children’s memory and ensure public confidence in justice.
The case against
Parole eligibility after 30 years was part of the law under which Smith was sentenced, and eligibility allows a board to assess her current circumstances rather than impose release automatically. A fair decision could focus on evidence about her rehabilitation, risk and conduct in prison, while recognising that the father’s understandable distress, though significant, cannot alone determine whether she remains imprisoned.