World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Susan Smith’s ex-husband wants her ‘in prison until she dies’ after killing sons in alleged bid to win lover
Susan Smith’s ex-husband, David Smith, says she should remain in prison for life as a parole board prepares to consider her release. Smith was convicted of murdering their two young sons in 1994, and the decision matters to the family after decades of grief.
The seven-member South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons is due to hear her request on Thursday. Sentenced to life in 1995, Smith became eligible for parole after 30 years under the law then in force; a later change barred parole for people sentenced to life for murders committed after 1 January 1996. Prosecutors said she drowned the boys to pursue a relationship with a lover, while her defence described her as severely depressed and said she had intended to die alongside them.
In short
- David Smith opposes his ex-wife’s parole.
- Susan Smith was convicted of killing their two sons in 1994.
- A South Carolina board is due to consider her release.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Smith’s ex-husband and others who oppose release can argue that the deliberate killing of two young children was exceptionally grave, and that the lasting harm to their family deserves substantial weight in the parole decision. They may also believe that life imprisonment should mean continued confinement in such a case, particularly when the victims cannot speak for themselves.
The case against
Those who support considering release can argue that Smith was sentenced under the law then in force, which made her eligible to seek parole after 30 years, and that eligibility warrants an individual review rather than automatic exclusion. They may ask the board to weigh her conduct and circumstances over the decades in prison, including the defence account of severe depression and suicidal intent, while recognising that parole consideration does not guarantee release.
Explained simply
Susan Smith was convicted of killing her two sons, Michael and Alex, in South Carolina in 1994. The case drew national attention after she initially said the boys had been abducted.
Smith received a life sentence in 1995, under rules that allowed some people serving life sentences to seek parole after 30 years. South Carolina later changed the law to bar parole for people sentenced to life for murders committed from 1 January 1996, so the date of Smith’s crime is central to her eligibility.
Prosecutors argued that Smith killed the boys to pursue a relationship with a man she was seeing; her defence said she was severely depressed and had intended to die with them. David Smith, the boys’ father and her former husband, is among the family members affected by the parole process.