Scotland’s free Primary One schoolbags will be made in China
Scotland’s free schoolbags for new Primary One pupils will be manufactured in China, despite the £6.5 million scheme being promoted by First Minister John Swinney ahead of the Holyrood election. The decision has drawn criticism from politicians and Scottish manufacturers, who say it sends public money overseas while local firms miss out.
The bags are due to be provided from next August and will be filled with school supplies sourced from Britain and Europe. A Scottish bag maker said the expected price of about £5 per bag would be impossible for local businesses to match while paying UK wages. Critics also called for assurances that the bags are not produced using child labour, amid wider debate over public contracts awarded to Chinese companies.
In short
- Scotland’s free P1 schoolbags will be made in China.
- The £6.5 million scheme has faced criticism.
- Local manufacturers say they cannot match the expected price.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Making the bags in China may allow the scheme to provide a large number of pupils with a useful start-of-school item within its budget. If overseas production offers the required price and capacity, choosing it could help ensure the public commitment is delivered on time while keeping funds available for other education needs.
The case against
A publicly funded scheme could be expected to support domestic jobs and give Scottish manufacturers a fair chance to supply it, especially when local firms say the target price is unattainable under UK wage costs. Critics may also reasonably seek clear safeguards on labour standards and supply-chain oversight, given the concerns raised about production in China.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Swinney’s free schoolbags for every Scottish P1 pupil are to be manufactured… in CHINA!”.