New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
TARJA TURUNEN Reflects On Her Exit From NIGHTWISH: ‘I Probably Should Have Put Them Through Hell’
Tarja Turunen, the former Nightwish vocalist, has spoken candidly about her acrimonious 2005 departure from the band, telling Metal Hammer magazine she regrets not pursuing legal action against her former bandmates. She said contracts and her contractual rights would have put the group "in deep shit for a long time" had she chosen to enforce them, but she opted instead to walk away without a fight, a decision she now views with some regret.
Turunen was dismissed from Nightwish at the end of the band's 2005 tour via an open letter, also published on the band's website, in which her bandmates accused her of prioritising business and money over the group's emotional bonds. She described the aftermath as devastating, saying she was hounded by Finnish tabloids for weeks and ultimately left the country for Buenos Aires, with the fallout affecting her family and friends as well as her ability to trust others. She has previously ruled out a full reunion with the band, though she remains in occasional contact with founder Tuomas Holopainen, and her husband Marcelo Cabuli separately pursued and lost a defamation lawsuit in 2011 over Nightwish's official biography.
In short
- Tarja Turunen regrets not taking legal action after her 2005 Nightwish firing
- She says the split's aftermath was "nasty" and damaged her personally
- She remains open to future forgiveness but ruled out rejoining the band
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Tarja was a founding member whose contributions made Nightwish's international success possible, yet was dismissed through public humiliation via an open letter without meaningful recourse. She possessed legitimate contractual rights that could have held the band accountable for their treatment, but choosing not to enforce them validated that public shaming is an acceptable industry practice and denied her the vindication that pursuing her claims might have provided. Her regret reflects a justified recognition that accepting such treatment passively abandons her rights and leaves her without accountability.
The case against
Whilst the dismissal was undoubtedly handled poorly, litigation would have prolonged Turunen's trauma through years of legal conflict rather than providing genuine healing. Her subsequent flourishing as a solo artist demonstrates she did not require legal vindication to rebuild her career and life, suggesting that walking away, though profoundly painful, ultimately served her wellbeing better than pursuing retribution would have. Sometimes the healthier choice is accepting loss and moving forward, even when one has legal grounds to fight.
Explained simply
Nightwish are a Finnish symphonic metal band, formed in 1996 by songwriter and keyboard player Tuomas Holopainen. Tarja Turunen was their original lead singer, and her operatic vocals became a defining part of the group’s early sound.
Turunen’s departure in 2005 followed a long tour and a public dispute with her bandmates. They announced her dismissal in an open letter, and the fallout became a major story in Finland, affecting her personal life and her relationship with the band.
The dispute also involved contracts and legal claims, including a defamation case brought by Turunen’s husband that was dismissed in 2011. Turunen has since pursued a solo career; she and Holopainen have occasional contact, but she has ruled out a full reunion.