Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Tech tycoon pays huge swarm of protesters to picket Saks flagship store after his mother was fired for filming customer who attacked her
A technology entrepreneur, Jeffrey Vinokur, has paid for daily protests outside Saks Fifth Avenue after the retailer fired his mother, who says a customer assaulted her at work. The dispute has drawn attention to how Saks handled the incident and the subsequent dismissal.
Vinokur says he has spent $12,600 on 15 protesters to picket Saks, and a further $1,800 on a protest at sister retailer Bergdorf Goodman. His 62-year-old mother had worked at Saks for about two weeks when the customer attacked her on 28 June; she was treated in hospital for minor injuries. Police said the customer was arrested and pleaded guilty to assault and aggravated harassment, while Saks fired the employee five days after the incident. Vinokur is seeking an apology from Saks’ chief executive, an investigation and action against those responsible.
In short
- A customer assaulted a Saks employee, who was later fired.
- Her son has paid $14,400 for protests at two stores.
- He is seeking an apology and an investigation.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Saks had a responsibility to protect staff and respond fairly after an employee was assaulted at work; firing her soon afterwards, particularly if it was connected to filming or reporting the incident, could discourage workers from seeking help. Vinokur’s protests may draw attention to the dismissal and press the company to explain its decision, investigate the handling of the case and consider an apology or other remedy.
The case against
Saks may have had reasons for dismissing the employee that are not fully described in the report, and the timing alone does not establish that the decision was retaliation for filming the incident. A company can reasonably expect staff to follow workplace rules while still addressing an assault, and a large paid protest may put pressure on the retailer before all the facts are clear; a fair investigation would help establish what happened and whether the dismissal was justified.