World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Teen killer who held down Tessa Majors while pal plunged knife into her heart freed early — despite violence behind bars
Luchiano Lewis, one of the teenagers convicted in the 2019 killing of Barnard student Tessa Majors, was released from prison on 14 October after serving about three years in state prison. His release has drawn attention because he was sentenced to nine years to life and had a record of violence in juvenile detention.
Lewis was 14 when he helped restrain 18-year-old Majors during a robbery in Morningside Park; Rashaun Weaver stabbed her four times, including once in the heart. Weaver is serving 14 years to life, while Lewis was freed on conditional release without a parole hearing. State law permits automatic release after two-thirds of a minimum sentence, though officials can withhold it in cases involving violence in custody.
In short
- Luchiano Lewis was released after about three years in state prison.
- He had been sentenced to nine years to life for his role in Tessa Majors’ killing.
- His juvenile detention record included assaults and weapons offences.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Conditional release can reflect a legal system’s commitment to predictable sentences and rehabilitation: Lewis served the applicable portion of his minimum term, and release may be justified if officials judge that continued imprisonment is not necessary to protect the public. His age at the time of the offence also supports giving weight to the possibility of change, while supervision in the community can provide accountability.
The case against
The killing was exceptionally grave: Lewis helped restrain Majors during the robbery in which she was fatally stabbed, and his sentence was nine years to life. Releasing him after about three years, particularly given reported violence in detention and the absence of a parole hearing, can raise concerns about public safety, whether the law’s custody-violence exception was properly applied, and whether the punishment adequately reflects the harm caused.
Explained simply
Tessa Majors was an 18-year-old student at Barnard College in New York. In December 2019, she was robbed and fatally stabbed in Morningside Park by teenagers; Luchiano Lewis was 14 at the time, and Rashaun Weaver carried out the stabbing.
Lewis and Weaver were convicted in connection with the killing and received different sentences. Lewis’s sentence was nine years to life, while Weaver’s was 14 years to life. In New York, some prisoners can be released automatically after serving two-thirds of a minimum term, subject to rules that can take behaviour in custody into account.