The 1969 song Linda Ronstadt knew never belonged on American radio: “His best stuff got driven out of him”

← Back to the feed

The 1969 song Linda Ronstadt knew never belonged on American radio: “His best stuff got driven out of him”

Far Out · 4 hours ago

Linda Ronstadt argued that Frank Sinatra's signature 1969 hit "My Way" never truly belonged on American radio, believing the song lost its essence when adapted from its French original for an English-speaking, commercially minded audience. Her comments highlight a broader argument about authenticity in music: that reworking songs to fit mainstream American tastes can strip them of what made them work in the first place, even when the result becomes a career-defining hit.

"My Way" began life as a French composition before Paul Anka wrote new English lyrics for Sinatra, who went on to make it one of his most famous recordings. Ronstadt said that even Sinatra himself regarded the Americanised version poorly, reportedly admitting the song was "horrible" despite its success. The episode also had an unexpected knock-on effect: David Bowie, who had written his own English lyrics for the same French melody only to be passed over in favour of Anka's version, is said to have channelled that experience into later work, illustrating how commercial compromise can inadvertently spur fresh creativity elsewhere.

  • Linda Ronstadt said Sinatra's "My Way" lost its essence in translation
  • Sinatra reportedly called the Americanised song "horrible" himself
  • Missing out on the French original inspired David Bowie's own music

Entertainment Music

Read the full article at the source →