New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
The 1999 performance Michael Caine got “slaughtered” for: “I can’t say I was shocked”
Michael Caine said his performance in *The Cider House Rules* was heavily criticised by British reviewers, a reaction he said did not surprise him given his long history of difficult relations with the UK press. The criticism helped prompt remarks at the BAFTAs about feeling like an outsider in his own country, which in turn caused controversy.
Released in 1999, *The Cider House Rules* featured Caine as Dr Wilbur Larch and was widely recognised elsewhere, while he felt British critics had been especially harsh. He linked this treatment partly to longstanding prejudice against his Cockney, working-class background, although he later noted that British film critics also awarded him Best Actor for *The Quiet American*.
In short
- Caine said British critics harshly attacked his *Cider House Rules* performance.
- He was unsurprised, citing years of negative UK reviews.
- The backlash fed his controversial BAFTA remarks.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Class prejudice has historically shaped British cultural gatekeeping, with working-class backgrounds and Cockney accents facing particular snobbery. When Caine's performance received harsh domestic reviews whilst gaining international recognition, and he subsequently felt dismissed at the BAFTAs, this pattern suggests systemic prejudice rooted in social hierarchy rather than legitimate artistic disagreement. His experience reflects broader institutional barriers that privilege certain accents and class positions.
The case against
Film criticism involves inherently subjective artistic judgements that vary between critics, publications, and countries for reasons beyond prejudice. Caine's subsequent major award for Best Actor from British critics for The Quiet American indicates the critical establishment is not systematically biased against him personally. Without examining the actual reviews' reasoning and comparing artistic merit, attributing negative criticism primarily to class prejudice rather than genuine performance assessment remains speculative.
Explained simply
The Cider House Rules is a 1999 film based on a novel by American writer John Irving. Michael Caine plays Dr Wilbur Larch, a doctor who runs an orphanage and helps women seeking abortions in the United States before they were widely legal.
Caine is a London-born actor who grew up in a working-class family and speaks with a Cockney accent. He has said that British press coverage of him was often hostile, and connected some of that treatment to his background.
The film received significant recognition outside Britain, while Caine recalled a harsher response from British reviewers. His comments about feeling an outsider in his own country at the BAFTAs drew controversy; later, British film critics gave him their Best Actor award for The Quiet American.