Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
The 7 Worst FPS Games From the 2000s
Polygon lists seven 2000s shooters it believes have aged poorly, arguing that technical flaws, disappointing execution or stronger later rivals have undermined their reputations. The article matters chiefly as a retrospective comparison: it distinguishes games that were influential or enjoyable in their day from those whose mechanics now feel dated.
Among the examples discussed are the original Call of Duty, judged eclipsed by Call of Duty 2; BlackSite: Area 51, criticised for unreliable squad commands and weak enemy AI; and Haze, whose hype exceeded its delivery despite Free Radical’s pedigree. Fallout 3 is praised as an exceptional role-playing game with strong quests and world-building, but faulted as a shooter because aiming and manual gunplay are poor without its VATS targeting system.
In short
- The article revisits shooters that no longer hold up.
- Later games exposed flaws in Call of Duty and BlackSite.
- Fallout 3 succeeds as an RPG, not a shooter.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
These games demonstrate genuine technical and design failures—BlackSite's unreliable squad AI, Fallout 3's clunky gunplay outside VATS, Haze's disappointing execution—that transcend simple ageing. Some were outpaced by superior successors, whilst others never functioned well and have rightly faded from prominence. Such flaws were not universal in the 2000s, suggesting these games were genuinely poorly designed by their era's standards.
The case against
Retrospective 'worst' rankings often conflate inevitable technical ageing with poor design, unfairly judging 2000s games by contemporary standards. Many titles were influential, innovative or genuinely enjoyable when released; Fallout 3 was designed as an RPG first and shooter second, so judging its gunplay harshly misses its real achievements. Such rankings require clearer criteria than 'hasn't aged well'—historical significance, ambition and reception merit equal consideration.
Explained simply
First-person shooters, or FPS games, put players in the role of a character who uses weapons and sees the action through that character’s eyes. The 2000s were a period of rapid change for the genre, as new consoles and computer hardware allowed larger worlds, more detailed graphics and online play.
The games in this debate include major series such as Call of Duty, as well as less successful releases such as BlackSite: Area 51 and Haze. Fallout 3 is mainly a role-playing game, where players explore a world and develop a character, but it also includes shooting.
Judging older games can depend on what players expected at the time and how later games changed the genre. A game may have been influential or enjoyable on release, yet feel awkward beside newer rivals or when revisited years later.